USER’S MANUAL
Section 6: AUDIO CODING REFERENCE 125
• Usethemaximumbitrateyoucanaffordateachstage.
Harddiskrecordersandotherstudiosystemsoftenhaveanoptiontoadjust
this.Forverycriticalwork,rememberthatZephyrXstreamhasseveral
modeswhereamonoprogramissplitovertwodigitalnetworkchannels,
therebycuttingthecompressionratioby50%.
• Getth
eMPEG2AACandMPEG4AAC‐LDadvantageonlowbitratechannels.
• Whenusingdedicatedlines,considerusingV.35Singlemode(seeAppendix
6‐SpecialOperationalModes)at256or384kbpstoallow"headroom"for
othercodinginthechain.
Mixed MPEG Signal Chains
Whataboutthecasewher
eyouwillbeusingLayers2,3andAACinasignalchain?Itturnsout
thatthetwomethodsarenicelycomplimentary.
Atlowbit‐rates,AACorLayer‐3getsmoresignal‐to‐maskmarginthanLayer‐2.Thisiswhythey
performbetterinthelowbit‐ratetests.Itaccomplis
hesthisbyusingafilterbankwithmore
bands,2048vs576vs32.Oneeffectofthisis“timespread.”(Morefrequencyresolution
requiresalongertimewindow.It’salawofphysicsthing...)Forasmallnumberofpasses(one
ortwo),thisisgood,asth
eearhasmaskinginthetimedomainaswellasthefrequencydomain,
andLayer‐3naturallyexploitsthisadditionaldimension.Thedown‐sideisthatwhenmany
stagesofLayer‐3areusedatlowbit‐rates,thetimespreadcanbecomeaudible(softeningof
transientsandpre‐echoes,mostly),andthisisabadthing.W
hileLayer‐2doesnothavethis
problem,ithasanother.Sinceitisclosertotheedgeforsignal‐to‐noise,multiplegenerations
resultinunmasking(noiseandgrit,mostly).
ButtheISO/MPEGpeopledonotproposethatabu
nchofpassesofLayer‐3beused.Theideais
thatAACorLayer‐3beusedatISDN/SW56bit‐ratesforfieldpick‐upandthatLayer‐2beusedat
higherbit‐ratesinotherpartsofthesignalpath.
ThisiswhytheISOgroupdecidedtorecommendtheLayersasthe
ydid:AACfor64kbps/channel
andLayer‐2forequaltoorgreaterthan128kbps/monochannel.
Ourownexperimentswithcodeccascadingconfirmthatthisistherightapproach:thetwo
codingmethodsseemtocomplementeachother.TwopassesofLayer‐3(stereo@128kbp
s)
soundnoticeablybetterthantwoofLayer‐2;apassofLayer‐3followedbyapassofLayer‐2also
soundsbetterthantwoofLayer‐2.Moreover,we’vehadcustomerswhohaveusedapass,or
two,ofLayer‐3followedbySEDATwithoutevidentproblems.