Telos Zephyr Xstream Two-Way Radio User Manual


 
USER’S MANUAL
Section 6: AUDIO CODING REFERENCE 118
AAC-LD (AAC Low Delay)
Whenannouncersusecodecsforbroadcastremoteapplications,theyoftenneedtohave
naturaltwowayinteractionwithotherprogramparticipantslocatedbackatthestudio,or
callers.BecauseitisahottopicforengineersworkinginthefieldofInternettelephony,a
numberofstudieshavebeenconductedtodeter
mineuser’sreactionstodelaysintelephone
conversations.Thedataapplydirectlytotheapplicationofprofessionalcodecstoremotes,soit
isinterestingtotakeapeakovertheshoulderofthetelecomguystoseewhattheyhave
learned.
Forbroadcastremotes,wetrytoarrangeoursystemsotha
tthereisnopathforthefield
announcer’svoicetoreturntohis/herheadphones.Nevertheless,sometimesechois
unavoidable.Forexample,thiscanhappenwhenatelephonehybridhasleakageorwhena
studioannouncerhasopenairheadphonesturneduploudandtheaudiomakesitswayin
tothe
studiomicrophone.
Whenthereisnoecho,ithasbeendiscoveredthatanythinglessthan100msonewaydelay
permitsnormalinteractionbetweenparticipants.Between100and250msisconsidered
“acceptable.”ITUTstandardG.114recommends150msasthemaximumfor“good”
interactivity.Echointroducesadifferentcase.Asyo
umightexpect,echoismoreorless
annoyingdependinguponboththelengthoftimeitisdelayedanditslevel.Telephone
researchershavemeasuredandquantifiedreactions,andITUTG.131reportsthefindingsand
makesrecommendations.
Summary of ITU-T G.13, with recommendations for designers of telephone systems that must cope
with echo. This shows Talker Echo Loudness Rating vs delay.
Therearecodecsusingotherthanperceptualtechnologiesthathavelowerdelay,buttheyare
notaspowerful.Thatis,foragivenbitrate,theydonotachievefidelityasgoodastheMPEG
systemswehavebeenexamining.ThecommonG.722isanexample.ItusesADPCM(Adaptive
DeltaPulseCo
deModulation),whichcanhavedelayaslowas10ms,butwithmuchpoorer
quality.Sothequestionarises:Isitpossibletohavehighqualityandlowdelayinthesame